Underwood Manor Review: What Guests Love Most (Pros, Cons & Honest Take)

TL;DR – The Honest Verdict

Underwood Manor is worth it if your group wants:

• A private house designed for groups (sleeps 10 comfortably)

• Built-in entertainment you’ll actually use

• A speakeasy-style game room that becomes the social hub

• A private hot tub, fire pit, and fenced backyard

• Quick access to Broadway without noise or parking headaches

It may not be the best fit if you require walkability to Broadway or daily hotel-style housekeeping.

What Guests Love Most

When you read through guest feedback, the same themes show up again and again. This isn’t random—it’s the result of intentional design.

Guests consistently mention:

• “Everything was exactly like the photos”

• “The house was the highlight of the trip”

• “We actually used all the amenities”

• “Perfect for our bachelorette group”

• “Close to Broadway but quiet at night”

Let’s break down why those comments keep repeating.

The House Is Built for Groups

Many Airbnbs say they’re group-friendly, but once you arrive, the layout doesn’t support how groups actually move.

Underwood Manor does.

Why the Layout Works

• Open-concept living room where everyone fits

• Multiple hang zones so the group doesn’t bottleneck

• Bedrooms positioned for privacy, not noise bleed

• Indoor + outdoor flow that feels natural

Guests regularly say it felt easy to be together without feeling crowded.

The Speakeasy Game Room Is a Standout Feature

If there’s one feature guests talk about most, it’s the dark, moody speakeasy-style game room.

This isn’t a leftover garage or a bright bonus room—it’s a deliberately styled space that feels like a private lounge.

What’s Inside

• Full-size 8-foot pool table

• Darts

• Mounted wall chess board

• 55” Smart TV

• Whiskey barrel bar

• Neon lyric sign glowing: “Blame it all on my roots, I showed up in boots.”

Why Guests Love It

• Becomes the pregame headquarters

• Perfect for late-night hangs without noise stress

• Photographs beautifully

• Feels unique—not like every other Nashville Airbnb

Many reviews describe this room as unexpected and memorable.

Private Backyard = Big Value for Groups

Another feature that shows up constantly in reviews is the private, fenced backyard.

Backyard Highlights

• 7-person premium hot tub

• Smokeless Solo Stove fire pit (unlimited firewood)

• Bistro string lights

• Cornhole, Can Jam & bocce ball

• Weber charcoal grill

Guests often mention:

• Spending an entire night in the backyard

• Loving the smokeless fire pit (no clothes smell)

• Using the hot tub daily—even in cooler months

For groups, this replaces paid activities and adds real value.

Built-In Entertainment Saves Time & Money

Underwood Manor shines because you don’t have to plan fun—it’s already there.

Inside the House

• Karaoke machine

• Pac-Man arcade

• 1,000-in-1 retro game console

• Record player with country vinyl

• Board games and puzzles

Guests frequently say:

• “We didn’t even go out one night because the house was so fun”

• “Perfect for pregames”

• “Great for rainy days or late nights”

That’s not just fun—it’s savings.

Comfortable Sleeping

Uncomfortable beds are one of the most common Airbnb complaints. Underwood Manor avoids that.

Sleeping Setup

• King Saatva Loom & Leaf mattress in the primary suite

• Queen Purple mattresses in additional bedrooms

• White noise machines

• Light-minimizing curtains

Reviews consistently mention:

• “The beds were so comfortable”

• “Everyone slept great”

• “No one felt stuck with the bad room”

For a multi-day trip, this matters more than most people expect.

Getting Ready Is Easy

Guests often underestimate how important getting-ready space is—until they have it.

Underwood Manor includes:

• Glam areas with vanity mirrors

• Full-length mirrors in bedrooms

• Good lighting throughout

• Insta-worthy decor so you don’t need to decorate

Bachelorette groups regularly say the house already set the vibe.

Location Without the Noise

Location is one of the most praised aspects.

Underwood Manor is:

• ~5 minutes to Downtown

• ~7 minutes to Broadway

• Easy Uber/Lyft pickup and drop-off

• Quiet residential neighborhood

• Includes free parking

Guests love being close enough to everything—without hearing it at 2 a.m.

The “Cons”

No place is perfect. Here’s what to know going in.

Con #1: Not Walkable to Broadway

• You’ll need Ubers or to drive

• Most groups prefer this trade-off for space and privacy

• Short rides, not long commutes

Con #2: Not a Hotel

• No daily housekeeping

• No front desk

• You’re in a private home (which most guests prefer)

Con #3: Best for Groups of 6–10

• Ideal size range is 6–10 guests

• Larger groups may need a bigger property like Ultimate Bach Pad

These aren’t deal-breakers—just good to know.

Who Underwood Manor Is Perfect For

Underwood Manor is an excellent fit if you’re planning:

• Bachelorette parties

• Girls trips

• Birthday weekends

• Friend group getaways

• Small family gatherings

It’s especially ideal if you want the house to be part of the experience.

How It Compares to Other Popular Options

vs Downtown Condos

• ✔ More space

• ✔ Private amenities

• ✔ Fewer noise issues

• ✔ Free parking

vs Hotels

• ✔ Everyone stays together

• ✔ Built-in entertainment

• ✔ Better value per person

vs Large Party Houses

• ✔ More curated

• ✔ Better flow

• ✔ Feels intentional, not chaotic

For most groups, Underwood Manor hits the sweet spot.

🌟 Spotlight on Underwood Manor

✔ Sleeps 10 comfortably ✔ Speakeasy game room with pool table & neon sign ✔ Private hot tub & smokeless fire pit ✔ Designed for bachelorettes & groups ✔ Minutes from Broadway with free parking 👉 Book direct at UnderwoodManor.com

FAQs – Underwood Manor Review

Is Underwood Manor actually worth the price? Yes—especially for groups who will use the amenities. Many guests say the house itself was a highlight.

What do guests mention most in reviews? The game room, hot tub, comfort of the beds, and how easy it was for groups.

Is it good for first-time Nashville visitors? Absolutely. The location makes exploring easy without being overwhelming.

Can we book directly? Yes. Booking through UnderwoodManor.com avoids third-party fees.

Final Thoughts

Underwood Manor isn’t just highly rated—it’s consistently loved for the same reasons. When guests say they’d book again without hesitation, that’s the strongest review there is.

If you want a Nashville stay where the house enhances the trip instead of just hosting it, Underwood Manor delivers.